NJ assisted suicide legislation nears tipping point

July 29, 2019 at 12:37 p.m.
NJ assisted suicide legislation nears tipping point
NJ assisted suicide legislation nears tipping point


By EmmaLee Italia | Contributing Editor

Physician-assisted suicide has been considered by the state Legislature without passing for more than six years. Now, with the legislation likely to be brought to a vote soon, there may be enough votes necessary to get it passed.

The “Aid in Dying for Terminally Ill Act” (A1504) is expected to be up for a vote Oct. 29 in the Assembly. The state Senate could move an identical bill (S1072) forward if the Assembly bill passes.

The bill would allow terminally ill adults of sound mind to obtain drugs they could take to hasten their demise. If passed, the bill could be on Gov. Phil Murphy’s desk before end of year.

The New Jersey Catholic Conference, the public policy arm of the state’s bishops, opposes the bill for various reasons, including the potential for abuse and the message it sends to the suffering.

“Physician-assisted suicide is a direct threat to anyone viewed as a significant cost liability to a health care provider,” said Patrick Brannigan, NJCC executive director. “The bill would allow the death certificate to list the cause of death as the underlying terminal disease … that misstatement on a legal document is the filing of a fraudulent report … [and] if we pass a law that says it is OK to end your life if you have pain – physical or psychological – what would we be telling our youth [and military] who are troubled?”

On Oct. 1, Oregon-based group Compassion and Choices launched a $1 million sustained digital video ad campaign featuring terminally ill advocates and their loved ones urging New Jersey lawmakers to pass the bill.

Meanwhile the bill sponsor, Assemblyman John J. Burzichelli (D-Gloucester / Salem / Cumberland), says there are sufficient votes to pass the bill .

“I’m confident that the votes are not only in the Assembly, but now there are sufficient votes in the Senate – so the ability to get this to governor’s desk is very high,” Assemblyman Burzichelli said in a Sept. 29 interview with KYW 1060 AM News Radio reporter David Madden.

This, Brannigan suggested, makes it important for people to contact their representatives immediately and ask them to vote “no.”

“Legislators always listen to their constituents,” Brannigan said. “If they do not hear from people opposing the bill, they might think their constituents support an issue.”

The goal of medical science, Brannigan underscored, is to eradicate illnesses, not the patients who suffer from them.

“Our duty is to assist those who are suffering, not kill them,” Brannigan said. “If medical doctors were to use their skills to help people kill themselves, they would be violating their sacred oath.”

He noted the advances made in pain management through palliative and hospice care, saying the efforts should instead be focused on the improvement and awareness of these options.

“In 2014, the state of New Jersey established the New Jersey Advisory Council on End-of-Life Care with a mandate to submit a report with recommendations on end-of-life care to the governor and the Legislature,” Brannigan continued. “I urge the Legislature to work with the New Jersey Advisory Council on End-of-Life Care rather than passing A1504.”

 

 

[[In-content Ad]]

Related Stories

By EmmaLee Italia | Contributing Editor

Physician-assisted suicide has been considered by the state Legislature without passing for more than six years. Now, with the legislation likely to be brought to a vote soon, there may be enough votes necessary to get it passed.

The “Aid in Dying for Terminally Ill Act” (A1504) is expected to be up for a vote Oct. 29 in the Assembly. The state Senate could move an identical bill (S1072) forward if the Assembly bill passes.

The bill would allow terminally ill adults of sound mind to obtain drugs they could take to hasten their demise. If passed, the bill could be on Gov. Phil Murphy’s desk before end of year.

The New Jersey Catholic Conference, the public policy arm of the state’s bishops, opposes the bill for various reasons, including the potential for abuse and the message it sends to the suffering.

“Physician-assisted suicide is a direct threat to anyone viewed as a significant cost liability to a health care provider,” said Patrick Brannigan, NJCC executive director. “The bill would allow the death certificate to list the cause of death as the underlying terminal disease … that misstatement on a legal document is the filing of a fraudulent report … [and] if we pass a law that says it is OK to end your life if you have pain – physical or psychological – what would we be telling our youth [and military] who are troubled?”

On Oct. 1, Oregon-based group Compassion and Choices launched a $1 million sustained digital video ad campaign featuring terminally ill advocates and their loved ones urging New Jersey lawmakers to pass the bill.

Meanwhile the bill sponsor, Assemblyman John J. Burzichelli (D-Gloucester / Salem / Cumberland), says there are sufficient votes to pass the bill .

“I’m confident that the votes are not only in the Assembly, but now there are sufficient votes in the Senate – so the ability to get this to governor’s desk is very high,” Assemblyman Burzichelli said in a Sept. 29 interview with KYW 1060 AM News Radio reporter David Madden.

This, Brannigan suggested, makes it important for people to contact their representatives immediately and ask them to vote “no.”

“Legislators always listen to their constituents,” Brannigan said. “If they do not hear from people opposing the bill, they might think their constituents support an issue.”

The goal of medical science, Brannigan underscored, is to eradicate illnesses, not the patients who suffer from them.

“Our duty is to assist those who are suffering, not kill them,” Brannigan said. “If medical doctors were to use their skills to help people kill themselves, they would be violating their sacred oath.”

He noted the advances made in pain management through palliative and hospice care, saying the efforts should instead be focused on the improvement and awareness of these options.

“In 2014, the state of New Jersey established the New Jersey Advisory Council on End-of-Life Care with a mandate to submit a report with recommendations on end-of-life care to the governor and the Legislature,” Brannigan continued. “I urge the Legislature to work with the New Jersey Advisory Council on End-of-Life Care rather than passing A1504.”

 

 

[[In-content Ad]]
Have a news tip? Email [email protected] or Call/Text 360-922-3092

e-Edition


e-edition

Sign up


for our email newsletters

Weekly Top Stories

Sign up to get our top stories delivered to your inbox every Sunday

Daily Updates & Breaking News Alerts

Sign up to get our daily updates and breaking news alerts delivered to your inbox daily

Latest Stories


PHOTO GALLERY: Vocation Discernment Gathering
Bishop David M. O'Connell, C.M., hosted ...

From Chicago to Peru to Rome, Pope Leo remains 'one of us,' say US Catholics
A day before Pope Leo XIV spoke by livestream to teens ...

Gathering of prison ministers provided time to pray, network, share ideas
More than 30 women and men serving in jail and prison ministry ...

‘O Antiphons’: Advent prayers even the overscheduled can embrace

For ‘Gaudete Sunday’: Allowing joy to take root in us
Today the Church invites us into the radiant joy of “Gaudete Sunday,” a name drawn...


The Evangelist, 40 North Main Ave., Albany, NY, 12203-1422 | PHONE: 518-453-6688| FAX: 518-453-8448
© 2025 Trenton Monitor, All Rights Reserved.