Foreign agent law could jeopardize services to those 'who need them most,' says Caritas official
May 22, 2024 at 9:21 a.m.
OSV News – The leader of a Catholic nonprofit in the nation of Georgia is speaking out after that country's parliament passed controversial legislation on foreign agents – a measure she said "risks jeopardizing the provision of services to the beneficiaries who need them the most."
Anahit Mkhoyan, director of Caritas Georgia, issued a detailed statement shortly after Georgian lawmakers approved a bill on "Transparency of Foreign Influence" May 14, despite massive demonstrations that saw tens of thousands gather in Tbilisi to oppose the legislation.
The bill, shelved last year after it had sparked violent protests, was recently dusted off and reintroduced by the leading Georgia Dream party – whose de facto leader, former prime minister Bidzina Ivanishvili, is seeking a Moscow-facing path for the nation, which gained its independence from the Soviet Union in 1991.
The text of the bill specifies that organizations, activist groups and media outlets receiving more than 20% of their funding from abroad must register with Georgia's government as "agents of foreign influence." Brawls broke out in parliament during the two reading sessions for the legislation, which stands to endanger Georgia's bid for European Union membership.
Georgia's President Salome Zourabichvili vetoed the bill May 18, saying the measure violated Georgia's constitution and "all European standards," but the Georgian Dream majority is expected to overturn that decision, creating what Mkhoyan called "several difficulties" for Caritas Georgia and other charitable organizations providing social services to vulnerable populations.
As part of Caritas Internationalis, the universal Catholic Church's global federation of more than 160 humanitarian organizations, Caritas Georgia "has never exerted foreign influence in Georgia," said Mkhoyan. "It has always used the knowledge, good practices and resources of good-willed foreign people to assist the most vulnerable people in Georgia."
Founded in 1994, the agency has over the past 30 years assisted "thousands of beneficiaries," among them "children without parental care and the ones who are street-connected, the poor and homeless, lonely elderly individuals, people with disabilities, home care patients, victims of domestic violence, and voluntarily returned migrants," Mkhoyan said.
"We provide safe shelter and basic necessities (nutrition, healthcare, household needs) and promote education and employment," she said in her May 16 statement. "In addition to directly assisting vulnerable individuals, we have been promoting, developing, and strengthening rural communities for years. Furthermore, we promptly respond to disasters caused by natural and human conflicts."
In a previous interview with OSV News, Mkhoyan said that Caritas Georgia was that nation's largest social services provider – and she reiterated in her statement that work could only be accomplished with funding primarily from "organizations in the EU and the United States."
In her statement, Mkhoyan specified a number of ways in which the foreign agent legislation will restrict the work of charitable organizations.
The bill imposes an "increased administrative burden" of compliance that "could divert resources and attention away from providing essential services," while "navigating varying legal and regulatory frameworks could pose challenges," she said.
In addition, the legislation "may contribute to the stigmatization" of Caritas Georgia and similar entities, and "undermine the credibility and effectiveness" of agencies working to "better the (quality of life) of Georgian people," said Mkhoyan.
Donors themselves may become "hesitant" to continue their support, which in turn "could limit opportunities for collaboration and resource mobilization," leading to a downturn in both funds and in "international engagement and collaboration in addressing social issues," she said.
The law stands to raise privacy concerns for clients receiving services from Caritas Georgia and fellow agencies, "particularly if detailed information about beneficiaries and their needs is subject to disclosure requirements," Mhkoyan cautioned.
She warned that an absence of judicial review "leaves room for regulatory authorities or government agencies responsible for enforcing the bill's provisions to exercise their powers unchecked.
"This could create opportunities for abuse of power, including harassment, intimidation, or discriminatory treatment of charitable organizations based on factors such as their funding sources or perceived political affiliations," she said.
In addition, "there is a heightened risk that regulatory actions taken against charitable organizations, such as investigations, penalties, or sanctions, may be based on insufficient evidence or conducted in violation of legal rights and procedural safeguards," Mkhoyan said. "This could result in unjust outcomes and damage the reputation and credibility of affected organizations."
Mhkoyan said in her statement that while "transparency and accountability are important principles for charitable organizations," implementation of the bill should be "carefully balanced to avoid unintended consequences" that would ultimately harm vulnerable populations.
She also pointed out the bill seeks to address issues currently covered under Georgian law, which already requires "access to registration data of non-entrepreneurial (non-commercial) legal entities, information about grant projects, information about employees for tax purposes, tax reporting of non-entrepreneurial (non-commercial) legal entities, financial reporting of non-entrepreneurial (non-commercial) legal entities, accountability of charitable organizations (and) information about the organization's property.
"Moreover, Caritas Georgia publishes annual and audited reports on its website and social media, which contain detailed information about annual income and expenses, grants awarded, and donor/partner organizations (https://caritas.ge/media)," said Mkhoyan. "Additionally, Caritas Georgia's partner organizations prioritize financial and operational transparency, accountability, and high reliability standards, which precludes the possibility of risky actions by the receiving organization."
Gina Christian is a multimedia reporter for OSV News. Follow her on X (formerly Twitter) @GinaJesseReina.
The Church needs quality Catholic journalism now more than ever. Please consider supporting this work by signing up for a SUBSCRIPTION (click HERE) or making a DONATION to The Monitor (click HERE). Thank you for your support.
Related Stories
Monday, June 17, 2024
E-Editions
Events
OSV News – The leader of a Catholic nonprofit in the nation of Georgia is speaking out after that country's parliament passed controversial legislation on foreign agents – a measure she said "risks jeopardizing the provision of services to the beneficiaries who need them the most."
Anahit Mkhoyan, director of Caritas Georgia, issued a detailed statement shortly after Georgian lawmakers approved a bill on "Transparency of Foreign Influence" May 14, despite massive demonstrations that saw tens of thousands gather in Tbilisi to oppose the legislation.
The bill, shelved last year after it had sparked violent protests, was recently dusted off and reintroduced by the leading Georgia Dream party – whose de facto leader, former prime minister Bidzina Ivanishvili, is seeking a Moscow-facing path for the nation, which gained its independence from the Soviet Union in 1991.
The text of the bill specifies that organizations, activist groups and media outlets receiving more than 20% of their funding from abroad must register with Georgia's government as "agents of foreign influence." Brawls broke out in parliament during the two reading sessions for the legislation, which stands to endanger Georgia's bid for European Union membership.
Georgia's President Salome Zourabichvili vetoed the bill May 18, saying the measure violated Georgia's constitution and "all European standards," but the Georgian Dream majority is expected to overturn that decision, creating what Mkhoyan called "several difficulties" for Caritas Georgia and other charitable organizations providing social services to vulnerable populations.
As part of Caritas Internationalis, the universal Catholic Church's global federation of more than 160 humanitarian organizations, Caritas Georgia "has never exerted foreign influence in Georgia," said Mkhoyan. "It has always used the knowledge, good practices and resources of good-willed foreign people to assist the most vulnerable people in Georgia."
Founded in 1994, the agency has over the past 30 years assisted "thousands of beneficiaries," among them "children without parental care and the ones who are street-connected, the poor and homeless, lonely elderly individuals, people with disabilities, home care patients, victims of domestic violence, and voluntarily returned migrants," Mkhoyan said.
"We provide safe shelter and basic necessities (nutrition, healthcare, household needs) and promote education and employment," she said in her May 16 statement. "In addition to directly assisting vulnerable individuals, we have been promoting, developing, and strengthening rural communities for years. Furthermore, we promptly respond to disasters caused by natural and human conflicts."
In a previous interview with OSV News, Mkhoyan said that Caritas Georgia was that nation's largest social services provider – and she reiterated in her statement that work could only be accomplished with funding primarily from "organizations in the EU and the United States."
In her statement, Mkhoyan specified a number of ways in which the foreign agent legislation will restrict the work of charitable organizations.
The bill imposes an "increased administrative burden" of compliance that "could divert resources and attention away from providing essential services," while "navigating varying legal and regulatory frameworks could pose challenges," she said.
In addition, the legislation "may contribute to the stigmatization" of Caritas Georgia and similar entities, and "undermine the credibility and effectiveness" of agencies working to "better the (quality of life) of Georgian people," said Mkhoyan.
Donors themselves may become "hesitant" to continue their support, which in turn "could limit opportunities for collaboration and resource mobilization," leading to a downturn in both funds and in "international engagement and collaboration in addressing social issues," she said.
The law stands to raise privacy concerns for clients receiving services from Caritas Georgia and fellow agencies, "particularly if detailed information about beneficiaries and their needs is subject to disclosure requirements," Mhkoyan cautioned.
She warned that an absence of judicial review "leaves room for regulatory authorities or government agencies responsible for enforcing the bill's provisions to exercise their powers unchecked.
"This could create opportunities for abuse of power, including harassment, intimidation, or discriminatory treatment of charitable organizations based on factors such as their funding sources or perceived political affiliations," she said.
In addition, "there is a heightened risk that regulatory actions taken against charitable organizations, such as investigations, penalties, or sanctions, may be based on insufficient evidence or conducted in violation of legal rights and procedural safeguards," Mkhoyan said. "This could result in unjust outcomes and damage the reputation and credibility of affected organizations."
Mhkoyan said in her statement that while "transparency and accountability are important principles for charitable organizations," implementation of the bill should be "carefully balanced to avoid unintended consequences" that would ultimately harm vulnerable populations.
She also pointed out the bill seeks to address issues currently covered under Georgian law, which already requires "access to registration data of non-entrepreneurial (non-commercial) legal entities, information about grant projects, information about employees for tax purposes, tax reporting of non-entrepreneurial (non-commercial) legal entities, financial reporting of non-entrepreneurial (non-commercial) legal entities, accountability of charitable organizations (and) information about the organization's property.
"Moreover, Caritas Georgia publishes annual and audited reports on its website and social media, which contain detailed information about annual income and expenses, grants awarded, and donor/partner organizations (https://caritas.ge/media)," said Mkhoyan. "Additionally, Caritas Georgia's partner organizations prioritize financial and operational transparency, accountability, and high reliability standards, which precludes the possibility of risky actions by the receiving organization."
Gina Christian is a multimedia reporter for OSV News. Follow her on X (formerly Twitter) @GinaJesseReina.
The Church needs quality Catholic journalism now more than ever. Please consider supporting this work by signing up for a SUBSCRIPTION (click HERE) or making a DONATION to The Monitor (click HERE). Thank you for your support.