QUESTION: Does original sin need an update? Is a Crucifix necessary at Mass?

May 9, 2023 at 4:24 p.m.
QUESTION: Does original sin need an update? Is a Crucifix necessary at Mass?
QUESTION: Does original sin need an update? Is a Crucifix necessary at Mass?

By Jenna Marie Cooper

Q: My Catholic grandmother used to say that "original sin" was a sort of stamp all people since Adam and Eve have been born with, where God is still holding people guilty of Adam and Eve's sin of disobedience even up through today, and that unless this stamp is removed through baptism, people will automatically go to hell at death. This seems a bit extreme to me and perhaps a bit "old school." Wouldn't a more modern take on the subject be that all people, even up through today, are simply continuing in an exiled state from Eden – "perfection" – and that God through Jesus offers a return? (Location withheld) 

A: Thank you for this interesting question! First of all, I'm not sure exactly what you mean by "a more modern take." While over the centuries Catholic doctrine might be developed – that is, be explained in more detail and articulated with greater clarity – Catholic teaching itself doesn't change. So what was true in your grandmother's day is still true in ours, and will remain true even for your great-great-grandchildren. That being said, it is possible to explain unchanging Catholic teaching in new ways that could resonate better with different cultures and in different time periods. Older catechisms often referred to the "stain" of original sin, and it's not unreasonable to question whether this language may be potentially confusing or off-putting to younger generations. At face value, neither you nor your grandmother are incorrect in your descriptions of original sin, although perhaps your grandmother's terminology requires some additional context. Baptism does remove the "stamp" or "stain" of original sin, and this indeed makes it possible for us to live forever with God in heaven. But, this is not because God would otherwise desire to punish us in some legalistic or vengeful way. Additionally, the Catechism of the Catholic Church readily acknowledges that original sin is not the same as a personal choice to commit some evil act on our part (see CCC, No. 405).Funnily enough, your description of original sin as exile is actually very "old school" as well. The book of Genesis itself describes Adam and Eve as being specifically "banished" from the Garden of Eden (Gn 3:23). And many of us are familiar with the traditional prayer "Hail Holy Queen" (an English translation of the Latin chant "Salve Regina"), in which we ask for Our Lady's intercession for us, the "poor banished children of Eve," and then implore her to show us her son Jesus "after this, our exile."

Q: Our priest has recently stopped using the processional cross, and now we have no Crucifix on the altar during Mass or at any other time. I've always thought that there is supposed to be a Crucifix on the altar to remind us all of the suffering and passion of Christ. (Location withheld)

A: Yes, the General Instruction of the Roman Missal, the "instruction book" for how Mass is to be celebrated, specifically indicates that "on the altar or close to it, there is to be a cross adorned with a figure of Christ crucified" (GIRM, No. 117). Presumably, this is not only to remind us of Christ's Passion, but also to help call to mind how the holy sacrifice of the Mass is the same thing as Christ's original sacrifice of his life on Calvary. GIRM 117 goes on to tell us that a processional Crucifix may also be used for this purpose. But either way, it is clear that a Crucifix is required. If it looks as though your own parish is not following this norm, the best thing to do would be to share your concerns directly with your pastor in a respectful way. Sometimes your local diocesan liturgy office can also be a good resource for these kinds of liturgical questions.

Jenna Marie Cooper, who holds a licentiate in canon law, is a consecrated virgin and a canonist whose column appears weekly at OSV News. Send your questions to [email protected].


Related Stories

Q: My Catholic grandmother used to say that "original sin" was a sort of stamp all people since Adam and Eve have been born with, where God is still holding people guilty of Adam and Eve's sin of disobedience even up through today, and that unless this stamp is removed through baptism, people will automatically go to hell at death. This seems a bit extreme to me and perhaps a bit "old school." Wouldn't a more modern take on the subject be that all people, even up through today, are simply continuing in an exiled state from Eden – "perfection" – and that God through Jesus offers a return? (Location withheld) 

A: Thank you for this interesting question! First of all, I'm not sure exactly what you mean by "a more modern take." While over the centuries Catholic doctrine might be developed – that is, be explained in more detail and articulated with greater clarity – Catholic teaching itself doesn't change. So what was true in your grandmother's day is still true in ours, and will remain true even for your great-great-grandchildren. That being said, it is possible to explain unchanging Catholic teaching in new ways that could resonate better with different cultures and in different time periods. Older catechisms often referred to the "stain" of original sin, and it's not unreasonable to question whether this language may be potentially confusing or off-putting to younger generations. At face value, neither you nor your grandmother are incorrect in your descriptions of original sin, although perhaps your grandmother's terminology requires some additional context. Baptism does remove the "stamp" or "stain" of original sin, and this indeed makes it possible for us to live forever with God in heaven. But, this is not because God would otherwise desire to punish us in some legalistic or vengeful way. Additionally, the Catechism of the Catholic Church readily acknowledges that original sin is not the same as a personal choice to commit some evil act on our part (see CCC, No. 405).Funnily enough, your description of original sin as exile is actually very "old school" as well. The book of Genesis itself describes Adam and Eve as being specifically "banished" from the Garden of Eden (Gn 3:23). And many of us are familiar with the traditional prayer "Hail Holy Queen" (an English translation of the Latin chant "Salve Regina"), in which we ask for Our Lady's intercession for us, the "poor banished children of Eve," and then implore her to show us her son Jesus "after this, our exile."

Q: Our priest has recently stopped using the processional cross, and now we have no Crucifix on the altar during Mass or at any other time. I've always thought that there is supposed to be a Crucifix on the altar to remind us all of the suffering and passion of Christ. (Location withheld)

A: Yes, the General Instruction of the Roman Missal, the "instruction book" for how Mass is to be celebrated, specifically indicates that "on the altar or close to it, there is to be a cross adorned with a figure of Christ crucified" (GIRM, No. 117). Presumably, this is not only to remind us of Christ's Passion, but also to help call to mind how the holy sacrifice of the Mass is the same thing as Christ's original sacrifice of his life on Calvary. GIRM 117 goes on to tell us that a processional Crucifix may also be used for this purpose. But either way, it is clear that a Crucifix is required. If it looks as though your own parish is not following this norm, the best thing to do would be to share your concerns directly with your pastor in a respectful way. Sometimes your local diocesan liturgy office can also be a good resource for these kinds of liturgical questions.

Jenna Marie Cooper, who holds a licentiate in canon law, is a consecrated virgin and a canonist whose column appears weekly at OSV News. Send your questions to [email protected].

Have a news tip? Email [email protected] or Call/Text 360-922-3092

e-Edition


e-edition

Sign up


for our email newsletters

Weekly Top Stories

Sign up to get our top stories delivered to your inbox every Sunday

Daily Updates & Breaking News Alerts

Sign up to get our daily updates and breaking news alerts delivered to your inbox daily

Latest Stories


El Vaticano anuncia las fechas de la asamblea sinodal y la formación de grupos de estudio
La segunda asamblea del Sínodo de los Obispos...

El predicador papal comparte reflexiones en las redes sociales durante la Cuaresma
El cardenal acostumbrado a predicar a los pontífices ...

Registration open for March 2 young adult retreat in Toms River
Young adults age 18-39 are invited to ...

‘YOU ARE MINE’
UPDATE: At Rite of Election, Bishop says ‘being Catholic makes a difference’
Emilio Robles credits his fiancée and her family ...

Vices are 'beasts' of the soul that need taming, Pope says at Angelus
Vices, such as vanity and greed, are like "wild beasts" of the soul ...


The Evangelist, 40 North Main Ave., Albany, NY, 12203-1422 | PHONE: 518-453-6688| FAX: 518-453-8448
© 2024 Trenton Monitor, All Rights Reserved.