As UN debates Mideast conflict, Israeli-Palestinian orchestra models peace in concert

February 24, 2023 at 9:01 p.m.
As UN debates Mideast conflict, Israeli-Palestinian orchestra models peace in concert
As UN debates Mideast conflict, Israeli-Palestinian orchestra models peace in concert

By James Martone

UNITED NATIONS – At the United Nations headquarters in New York, international diplomats debated ways of peacefully resolving the intensifying Palestinian-Israeli conflict thousands of miles away.

As they did so, an orchestra made up of eight musicians from either side of that Middle Eastern divide were in the same building Feb. 23, performing a classical musical concert for a selected audience.

The octet was part of the larger West-Eastern Divan Orchestra composed of young musicians from Israel, Palestine and other Arab countries that was founded in 1999 by renowned Israeli musician Daniel Barenboim and late Palestinian scholar Edward Said as an alternative way to address the decades-long Palestinian-Israeli divide.

"This is a great opportunity to have them visit the United Nations, perform and talk about their work and the work of the orchestra," explained Maher Nasser, of the U.N.'s Department of Global Communications, when asked by OSV News about why the group was invited to play that day at the U.N., where ways of ending the world's various other conflicts, including the war in Ukraine, were at the center of debate as well.
[[In-content Ad]]

"The United Nations was created as an organization that brings people together to promote the ideals of peace, human rights, development, and that we can overcome the differences by engaging with each other, not by fighting with one another," said Nasser, speaking on the sidelines of the concert, held in a U.N. chamber hall that was only about half full.

"And it is an opportune moment to also reflect on the role of culture, the role of music in bringing people together, bringing what unites us," Nasser said.

The orchestra played several works by the 19th-century German composer Felix Mendelssohn under the close supervision of the orchestra's manager, Tabaré Perlas.

Though this was the first time the orchestra had ever performed at U.N. headquarters in New York, Perlas told OSV News the musicians had played at other famous world venues before, including Castel Gandolfo in 2012, upon a personal invitation from Pope Benedict XVI, who "was very happy to receive the orchestra there, and for the orchestra it was very special."

The goal of the ethnically diverse West-Eastern Divan Orchestra then and now, Perlas noted, is "to bring a message to the world."

"Of course, the conflict in the Middle East will not be solved by an orchestra playing together but we are just a model and an example. That is what we try to be," he said.

An Israeli member of the orchestra who played the viola at the U.N. concert, Miriam Manasherov, agreed, saying, "I think we set an example for ourselves as human beings."

"I think the idea is … we are all equal, we are equal in music, we are equal in life, and the fact that we can manage on a daily basis and actually become very good friends as well, for us it's a victory," she told OSV.

Her fellow musician and orchestra member, Palestinian violinist Samir Obaido, stood nearby.

"Sometimes we get into this hopeless state where we think nothing can be done, so as an individual you feel like you have little effect on society," said Obaido, who played violin at the U.N. concert.

But he quickly added, "Music for me is definitely one of the last resorts that we can kind of go to in our world at the moment if we want more kindness and goodness."

James Martone writes for OSV News from New York.


Related Stories

UNITED NATIONS – At the United Nations headquarters in New York, international diplomats debated ways of peacefully resolving the intensifying Palestinian-Israeli conflict thousands of miles away.

As they did so, an orchestra made up of eight musicians from either side of that Middle Eastern divide were in the same building Feb. 23, performing a classical musical concert for a selected audience.

The octet was part of the larger West-Eastern Divan Orchestra composed of young musicians from Israel, Palestine and other Arab countries that was founded in 1999 by renowned Israeli musician Daniel Barenboim and late Palestinian scholar Edward Said as an alternative way to address the decades-long Palestinian-Israeli divide.

"This is a great opportunity to have them visit the United Nations, perform and talk about their work and the work of the orchestra," explained Maher Nasser, of the U.N.'s Department of Global Communications, when asked by OSV News about why the group was invited to play that day at the U.N., where ways of ending the world's various other conflicts, including the war in Ukraine, were at the center of debate as well.
[[In-content Ad]]

"The United Nations was created as an organization that brings people together to promote the ideals of peace, human rights, development, and that we can overcome the differences by engaging with each other, not by fighting with one another," said Nasser, speaking on the sidelines of the concert, held in a U.N. chamber hall that was only about half full.

"And it is an opportune moment to also reflect on the role of culture, the role of music in bringing people together, bringing what unites us," Nasser said.

The orchestra played several works by the 19th-century German composer Felix Mendelssohn under the close supervision of the orchestra's manager, Tabaré Perlas.

Though this was the first time the orchestra had ever performed at U.N. headquarters in New York, Perlas told OSV News the musicians had played at other famous world venues before, including Castel Gandolfo in 2012, upon a personal invitation from Pope Benedict XVI, who "was very happy to receive the orchestra there, and for the orchestra it was very special."

The goal of the ethnically diverse West-Eastern Divan Orchestra then and now, Perlas noted, is "to bring a message to the world."

"Of course, the conflict in the Middle East will not be solved by an orchestra playing together but we are just a model and an example. That is what we try to be," he said.

An Israeli member of the orchestra who played the viola at the U.N. concert, Miriam Manasherov, agreed, saying, "I think we set an example for ourselves as human beings."

"I think the idea is … we are all equal, we are equal in music, we are equal in life, and the fact that we can manage on a daily basis and actually become very good friends as well, for us it's a victory," she told OSV.

Her fellow musician and orchestra member, Palestinian violinist Samir Obaido, stood nearby.

"Sometimes we get into this hopeless state where we think nothing can be done, so as an individual you feel like you have little effect on society," said Obaido, who played violin at the U.N. concert.

But he quickly added, "Music for me is definitely one of the last resorts that we can kind of go to in our world at the moment if we want more kindness and goodness."

James Martone writes for OSV News from New York.

Have a news tip? Email [email protected] or Call/Text 360-922-3092

e-Edition


e-edition

Sign up


for our email newsletters

Weekly Top Stories

Sign up to get our top stories delivered to your inbox every Sunday

Daily Updates & Breaking News Alerts

Sign up to get our daily updates and breaking news alerts delivered to your inbox daily

Latest Stories


Raising Catholic kids is intentional, Bishop says at NDHS talk
“Talk to your kids,” was the advice of Bishop David M. O’Connell, C.M. ...

Bonhoeffer: Pastor. Spy. Assassin.
In crafting the biopic "Bonhoeffer: Pastor. Spy. Assassin." (Angel), writer-director...

Novel set in Dante's 'Inferno' perfect reading for November
The month of November is a natural time to turn one's thoughts...

El Salvador charges ex-president for '89 Jesuit slayings
El Salvador has ordered a former president...

Cardinal warns war in Ukraine could spiral out of control
The situation in Ukraine is very "worrisome" and could spiral ...


The Evangelist, 40 North Main Ave., Albany, NY, 12203-1422 | PHONE: 518-453-6688| FAX: 518-453-8448
© 2024 Trenton Monitor, All Rights Reserved.