By Rosemary Daniels | Correspondent
The baby was a girl, born to Shirley Powell, a 16-year-old high school junior from Burlington County. What seemed to be missing, however, was the great joy that usually accompanies the birth of a healthy infant.
The year was 1973, and Powell was an unwed mother. Two months prior, Powell and her boyfriend had informed their parents about the pregnancy and were met with a response that broke the youths’ hearts: Powell’s parents, after consulting with Church officials, were encouraged to send their daughter to St. Elizabeth’s Home, Yardville – a home for unwed mothers. She would stay there until the baby was born. At that point, the baby would be given up for adoption.
The plan, Powell explained, “was to tell everyone that I was going to Florida to ‘help with my grandparents.’” But in reality, she would spend the next two months in a home with other unwed, pregnant girls under an assumed name and wait for her daughter to be born.
“Everyone had fake names, and some girls were pretty rough. I was terrified,” Powell said, explaining that many of the girls in the home were older and had a history of committing petty crimes.
Powell was more fortunate than some of her housemates. Where others had no contact with their families, Powell’s parents visited every week, and her grandparents would come periodically to take her to the movies.
During counseling sessions with a Catholic case worker, Powell was urged to place her baby up for adoption. Being the oldest of six children, she was told being an unwed mother was a bad influence on her siblings.
Without the financial support of her parents, Powell felt she was left with only one choice – to give her daughter up for adoption. Powell said she was told to go on with her life and not think about the baby again.
This proved impossible. Though Powell would go on to marry her high school sweetheart and raise two sons – Christopher, 34, and Timothy, 32, both policemen – she could never forget about her daughter.
“Each year on her birthday, I would get very depressed,” Powell said. “Because we had been told never to talk about it again, my husband wouldn’t even ask me why I was crying. It was very hard.”
Source of Support
Powell’s scenario was not unique 40 years ago, when society’s judgement of unmarried women having babies was harsh, and efforts were made, particularly within the Church, to keep these matters private. Because of this, many women have shared feelings of hurt and isolation.
Those feelings and the desire to help those in similar situations led two women from the Diocese of Camden – who were also sent to St. Elizabeth’s Home in the early 1970s – to create First Mother Family, a support group for birth mothers of children given up for adoption that Powell is now a part of.
“We are hoping to reach many other birth mothers in the area who might also be looking for support and understanding,” said Powell, a member of St. Isaac Jogues Parish, Marlton.
The group’s founders – Joan McCarthy and Mary Sharon Monaco – said they were fortunate to have found each other to serve as a sounding board over the years.
“We were blessed to have each other,” McCarthy said. “There was someone to check on how we were doing. We could talk about it with each other. Even today, talking about it makes our families uncomfortable.”
Monaco agreed, saying, “Joan was the only person I could talk to, the only one who understood. When we met with Shirley, we clicked. She knew that feeling, too.”
That need to find others with similar experiences is what continues to lead the women on their search for other birth mothers.
“We needed to do something for other women who have been through this,” McCarthy said. “We’re hoping to reconnect with some of the women who were at St. Elizabeth’s during that time.”
Reunion, it turns out, would be part of Powell’s story, too.
A Long Time Coming
Powell’s daughter, Lori Kundak, was adopted by a loving couple in Carteret. Currently married and living in North Carolina, Kundak did not find out about her adoption until she was 32 because of a family medical issue. She accessed her medical records through Catholic Charities – which has a long history of helping facilitate adoptions and encouraging birth parents to provide the Health Department with updated medical information – but the file also contained her biological parents’ information.
Kundak said she was reluctant to reach out to her birth mother at first.
Two years later, she contacted Catholic Charities again and was able to track down her biological father, Larry.
“Now that I was a parent myself, I realized that I’d want to know if my child was happy and healthy,” Kundak said. “I also just wanted to say ‘Thank you.’”
Although no longer married, Larry and Shirley Powell remain on good terms, and Larry Powell immediately contacted his ex-wife.
“We were so happy,” Shirley Powell said. “We arranged to get down there [North Carolina] as soon as we could.”
It was a joyous reunion, and the families visit each other frequently. It has been a healing opportunity for Shirley Powell’s parents, as well.
Powell recalled, “They were so excited when we called. My mom ran through the house calling to my dad, ‘They found Shirley’s baby!’” Prior to this, there had been virtually no discussion of the baby that had arrived Jan. 22, 1973.
Moving Forward
The adoption experience has left an indelible mark on Shirley Powell, as it did with many young unmarried mothers of that same era. While the reunion stories of McCarthy and Monaco have not had such happy endings – McCarthy reunited with her daughter, but is not currently in touch; Monaco’s son died in a tragic accident before they could be reunited – they were both glad to find out about their first child.
“Just finding out gave me such a sense of peace that she has been OK and has had a beautiful life with her adoptive parents,” McCarthy said.
Monaco contacted her child’s adoptive mother and received pictures of her son, which she treasures.
The new year will bring significant changes to birth families and adopted children. As of Jan. 1, 2017, adoptees 18 years or older, born or adopted in New Jersey, will be able to access their original birth certificate, including the names of the biological parents, under a bill Gov. Chris Christie signed into law in 2014. Birth parents will be able to select their contact preference – no contact, contact through a third party, or direct contact – but must do so by the end of this year.
Shirley Powell said being reunited with Kundak has brought healing.
“I know that not all birth mothers have been this fortunate,” she said. “The pain we share is very real.”
For more information about First Mother Family, email firstmotherfamily@gmail.com.
