In an interview with The Monitor, Melissa Dayton, service coordinator and religion teacher in Notre Dame High School, Lawrenceville, reflects on the concerns and needed responses to the Netflix series, “13 Reasons Why.” Dayton and her husband are founders of the suicide prevention organization, “You Cannot Be Replaced,” created in 2012 after a cluster of suicides in their local high school. Find them at www.youcannotbereplaced.com.
By Mary Morrell | Correspondent
QUESTION: As an educator and leader who works with youth, what are your concerns about this TV series?
ANSWER: It’s important to remember this show is for profit, not for education. When publicly discussing suicide, safe messaging is of prime importance. Statistics show that when information that is education-based is shared in the media, there is no negative outcome, but when heightened emotional stories are told including how, where, why, there is an increase of suicide in those areas. For teens, the instance of repeating a suicide when there has been one is also higher; we need to remember their brains are still developing and their impulses are highly emotion-spurred at times.
Related Story: Concern for youth triggers pushback against popular Netflix series depicting suicide
The quality of the film is well done – attractive actors, cool music and clothes, even the location is beautiful. Viewers are immediately drawn in. The problem with the quality drawing the viewers in is, the series is explicit, graphic and highly emotional, which could easily trigger a young person who is struggling or managing depression.
We have heard of mostly young teens and pre-teens binge watching the show without adults. There is a six-second delay between episodes, and it begins automatically. The result is complete saturation for 13 hours of intense, graphic content. Students of mine have regrettably told me that they should never have watched it, that they cannot “unsee” what they have watched.
Q: What messages are youth receiving from this series?
A: That they must handle hard things alone, that adults aren’t worth going to for help. A huge problem that is always being addressed in schools is that while developmentally it is normal for teens to turn to peers, when someone is in crisis, they need an adult. We spend hours on the phone and speaking with adults about the importance of improving communication and trust with teens so that they will be the ones teens turn to when needed.
Teens need us to remind them that even if it’s not them struggling, but a friend who is, they are not equipped to handle mental health issues without adult guidance. But, what they are equipped to do, and they need to know is also their responsibility to do, is to be a support and bring that friend to an adult. They cannot resolve these issues without adults and trained counselors.
The show also strongly states that when someone completes suicide, it is someone else’s fault – which is sadly wrong and what survivors and loved ones are burdened with for the rest of their lives. The show never addresses mental illness, which is, diagnosed or undiagnosed, the root of suicidal ideation.
Q: How are the adults/parents/teachers portrayed in the series?
A: The counselor, especially, in the show does not give the right answers and it was a waste of time to go to him. In reality, school counselors spend most of their time trying to build enough trust with teens to be the one they go to. The series destroyed so many good people’s efforts. School counselors are trained with a protocol to get students in crisis help; they know the questions to ask and what resources’ are available. No adult is perfect, and I’m sure there are some who have made poor decisions, but as a whole, the ones my husband and I work with are engaged with their students and put great effort into serving them.
Q: How are the series’ messages contrary to teachings of Catholic faith?
A: I’m not sure I have enough space to answer: the graphic sexual content, the drugs and alcohol, the disrespect for adults, the revenge and vindictive nature of the tapes, the lack of wisdom and counsel from the adults and no mention of hope, God or eternal life.
Q: Are the topics of this series – suicide, rape, bullying, shaming, loneliness – topics that are being discussed in other venues with youth?
A: Yes, I do believe all of the above are important topics that are definitely contributing factors to a teen in crisis (though not the only source). There are good programs out there, with reputable content or speakers, that can bring productive conversations to teens that add value to the adult they are growing into.
Schools do make efforts to provide this information to students. The most important place, though, for these conversations is at home. Parents need to remember they are the primary educators of their children. Kindness and compassion begin at home and need to be practiced and cultivated there, as well.
Discussing the hard things of life and reassuring our kids that we are there for them no matter what difficult situation they may find themselves in is what God assigned us to do for them. Those discussions need to happen continually, while driving, on walks, at the table. It can’t be one and done. We need to watch what their watching, listen to their music, put ourselves in their world and not assume their teen experience is like ours. Because it is not.
Q: What has been the response of students who are watching the series?
A: Upset. “Why did I watch it?” ‘It was awful.” “How does this series help anyone who wants to take their life?” “I can’t unsee it.” “It has messed me up.”
Q: Any other thoughts you may have on this topic?
A: Suicide is preventable. If we can get the person to the help they need, they can move forward, heal and live a productive life. Depression is something that many people have to learn to manage, just like a diabetic needs to manage insulin. A person with depression can learn to notice what triggers them, healthy ways to cope and focus on wellness. They can also put in place external supports and strong people that can help them when they are in need.
Community and people are essential. Building trust is equally important. We want teens to come to us so we can help them. We can have the best training in the country, but if they don’t trust us, they won’t come to us and we can’t help them. Adults may not have the answers, but we can get them to the people who are trained and do.
Church communities and pastors should be working hand in hand with prevention groups and coalitions. We need to go to where others are serving and be a bridge to faith communities so we can offer the path to Jesus and spiritual strength and healing so many families need. Suicide is not a common response to life’s problems, and it is not heroic; it is simply a dire response to deep emotional pain. We need to take seriously our call to live out the Gospel message and be reflections of hope.
I am worried for the young people we know who are survivors, who wonder what they could have done and then watched the show to figure it out. The grief and wounds have been reopened. I am worried for young teens whose parents have no idea their children have watched two graphic rapes and a suicide.
What do parents do? Read, find some good resources and then talk to your kids. Keep them close, and keep them talking. Remind them God created them unique and irreplaceable humans that have a purpose and a place in this world, even if at times they don’t feel like they do.
