By Rich Fisher | Correspondent
It was a homecoming for RJ Mathes, the first opportunity to see a legendary gym for Maddy McCauley and a chance for both Notre Dame High School freshman teams to put the future of Irish basketball on display.
The ND boys won the Mercer County CYO holiday tournament, taking a thrilling 73-71 victory over Ewing in the Dec. 23 semifinals and a 62-57 win over St. Joseph’s of Metuchen in the Dec. 27 title game. The Irish girls won their semifinal, 42-29, over Trenton and fell to perennial champion Hunterdon Central, 29-18, in the championship game.
Photo Gallery: Mercer County CYO Holiday Tournament
The games were played at the iconic CYO Center in Trenton, which is where Mathes played growing up.
“It was cool,” said Mathes, who was named Most Valuable Player of the title game. “It was a lot of memories. I played for Trenton Catholic, and we won a lot of championships, and then to come back in high school and win the championship and then get an award, it was like the same thing.”
McCauley, who scored 23 points in the win over Trenton, did not play CYO growing up but is impressed by its rich tradition.
“This was the first time that I had played there, and it was fun to play at the CYO after learning that they have a long history,” she said. “That it’s a Christian organization means a lot to me.”
Just as she and Mathes do a lot for their basketball teams.
In winning the boys crown, ND had to rally from an 18-point fourth-quarter deficit to overtake Ewing. Ricky Spruill was held to two points before exploding for 22 in the fourth-quarter comeback. With the game tied, ND got a steal and layup with three seconds remaining for the victory.
“I can’t even tell you how we did it, but it was fun,” coach Ryan Prendergast said. “That was probably the most hectic game I’ve ever been a part of.”
Spruill’s play was limited due to foul trouble, but Prendergast had no choice when the final period started. “I was like, ‘Hey, I’m gonna put you in for the fourth quarter until you foul out, so show me what you got.’ And he gave me 22.”
Christian Hobde added 12 points and six rebounds, Mike Jean and Chris Genicola had five points each and Patrick Prendergast made five steals. Aaron Forde chipped in with four points and five rebounds, while Eric Mally and Jaden Holmes each had three points.
“We kept our heads up, and we played the whole way through,” Mathes said. “I think we wore them down with the press.”
In the final, ND again trailed entering the fourth quarter, but only by three as they were able to use late heroics to win the game and trophy.
With Spruill fouling out, Mathes stepped up with 15 points and six rebounds. Also contributing were Hobde (9 points, 4 assists, 5 rebounds), Peter Alvarez (9 points, 7 rebounds, 2 steals), Prendergast (6 rebounds) and Spruill (9 points, 5 rebounds). Yaw Asante was the Irish’s defensive stopper, while Ethan Chambers hit some key free throws as the Irish improved to 5-0.
“This means a lot,” Mathes said. “The season’s still young, and we’re looking to get as many wins as we can and get as much chemistry as we can build together.”
The Irish girls are looking to do the same as they had a 4-1 record after falling to a Hunterdon Central team that has now won the CYO title five of the last six years.
“Hunterdon Central had a very talented team, and they were just a little better than us that day,” coach Carla Maccaroni said. “It showed us some stuff we have to work on.”
Against Trenton, ND overcame some first-half struggles to win convincingly as McCauley scored 14 of her 23 in the fourth quarter. Emily Reinstein and Ariana Garcia each had seven points, Olivia Okupski had three, Juliana Troiano two and Lauren Lencovich one.
Rounding out the roster were Sasha Jules, Lina Krokos, Christian Van Norden, Victoria Ramirez, Sarah Dunn, Giavanna Toto and Grace Telegadis.
Despite the loss, McCauley enjoyed the journey.
“Making it to the championship game was very exciting, especially playing with a new team,” she said. “It was very competitive and playing for a trophy was the best part. I do not think our team performed to the best to our ability in the final game. We are a new team, and we are still learning to play together. We played very well in some parts.”
Although it was McCauley’s first trip to the CYO center, it marked a return to the roots for her coach and some teammates.
“We like to do this tournament,” said Maccaroni, an ND grad. “We think it’s good for our girls. A lot of them played there. I played for Our Lady of Sorrows and TCA and went through it all, and I think it’s cool for the girls to go back and play there after doing it in middle school.”
