Catholic leaders, ethicists respond to passage of massive reconciliation bill July 4
July 5, 2025 at 2:08 p.m.
WASHINGTON -- President Donald Trump on July 4 signed a reconciliation bill enacting much of his legislative agenda on taxes and immigration during an Independence Day ceremony at the White House.
Previously, the U.S. House on July 3 approved the One Big Beautiful Bill Act in a 218-214 vote. The Senate earlier approved the reconciliation package on July 1, after Trump urged them to do so by July 4.
Only two Republicans -- Reps. Thomas Massie, Ky., and Brian Fitzpatrick, Pa., -- voted against the measure. Massie cited the bill's projected increase to the national debt, while Fitzpatrick, who is Catholic, cited the way Medicaid cuts would impact his district. All Democratic members of the House and Senate opposed the bill.
Catholic leaders have alternately praised and criticized various provisions in the legislation. But in a July 1 action alert emailed to its supporters, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops ultimately said the bill "currently fails the poorest families."
Archbishop Timothy P. Broglio, USCCB president and head of the U.S. Archdiocese for the Military Services, said in a July 3 statement after the vote, that he and the bishops had "repeatedly and consistently" urged lawmakers to make sure the bill would help families in need and "to change course" on aspects "that fail the poor and vulnerable."
"The final version of the bill includes unconscionable cuts to healthcare and food assistance, tax cuts that increase inequality, immigration provisions that harm families and children, and cuts to programs that protect God's creation," Archbishop Broglio said. "The bill, as passed, will cause the greatest harm to those who are especially vulnerable in our society. As its provisions go into effect, people will lose access to healthcare and struggle to buy groceries, family members will be separated, and vulnerable communities will be less prepared to cope with environmental impacts of pollution and extreme weather."
The USCCB president said, "More must be done to prevent these devastating effects." He noted the church's own teaching on human dignity and the common good compels it "to redouble our efforts and offer concrete help to those who will be in greater need and continue to advocate for legislative efforts that will provide better possibilities in the future for those in need."
House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., said at a press conference following the vote, "A lot of the estimations about what this legislation would do in a negative manner to communities in my state or any other are far overblown. I can tell you that this bill is going to be a great thing for everybody around the country, my constituents, especially.”
The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office estimated nearly 12 million people will lose health coverage under the legislation.
Ingrid Delgado, national director of public policy and advocacy for The Society of St. Vincent de Paul USA, told OSV News "such large cuts to the social safety net are really concerning, with how it'll impact our most marginalized."
"The Catholic Church approaches both access to food and health care as fundamental human rights," Delgado said. "And so the people who access SNAP in our country and the people who access Medicaid are our most marginalized and poorest brothers and sisters."
Delgado said cuts to those programs could lead to "more people who are uninsured, who don't have food on their tables, and more people facing the risk of homelessness."
The legislation will significantly increase funds for Immigration and Customs Enforcement, also known as ICE, and Customs and Border Patrol as the Trump administration seeks to implement its hardline immigration policies, including the mass deportation of immigrants lacking legal authorization to live and work in the U.S. It authorized about $150 billion in new spending for immigration and border enforcement.
Joan F. Neal, interim executive director of Network, a Catholic social justice lobby, said in a statement, "The damage done by this cruel, un-American bill will be devastating, intergenerational, and require decades-long reform to repair."
"People will die if the country robs millions of us of access to food and health care, creates even more obscene wealth inequality, and funds increasing detention, deportation, and ICE raids. The United States will be unrecognizable, and it will take a very long time to rebuild," Neal said. "This is a moral failure for the lawmakers who passed it and a betrayal of the trust of their constituents who elected them to look after their interests. They should be ashamed of themselves."
But others celebrated a provision in the legislation that would strip funds from Planned Parenthood for only one year -- down from an original proposal of 10 years -- with funding resumed thereafter.
Marjorie Dannenfelser, president of Susan B. Anthony Pro-Life America, told OSV News the day before the House vote that "this is the possible culminating point of the first year where federal taxpayers are not forced to fund Big Abortion and that would be huge."
Dannenfelser said that one year was the most amount of time they could achieve through the bill under Senate rules, which limit policy changes in reconciliation legislation.
"One year is a beginning, and it sets a new precedent, which is exactly what we want," she said.
In a fundraising pitch on its website, Planned Parenthood said the impact of the legislation "will be immediate and devastating."
"As many as 200 Planned Parenthood health centers are at risk of shutting down," they said.
The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office estimated the legislation would increase the deficit by nearly $3.3 trillion from 2025 to 2034. The U.S. national debt currently stands at $36.2 trillion, and has downstream impacts on the rest of society.
A June 26 letter to senators from the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops praised the provision that would strip funds from Planned Parenthood while opposing others that they said would raise taxes "on the working poor while simultaneously giving large tax cuts to the wealthiest." The letter added, "Because of this, millions of poor families will not be able to afford life-saving healthcare and will struggle to buy food for their children. Some rural hospitals will likely close." The bishops called these provisions "unconscionable and unacceptable."
Kate Scanlon is a national reporter for OSV News covering Washington.
Related Stories
Saturday, July 12, 2025
E-Editions
Events
WASHINGTON -- President Donald Trump on July 4 signed a reconciliation bill enacting much of his legislative agenda on taxes and immigration during an Independence Day ceremony at the White House.
Previously, the U.S. House on July 3 approved the One Big Beautiful Bill Act in a 218-214 vote. The Senate earlier approved the reconciliation package on July 1, after Trump urged them to do so by July 4.
Only two Republicans -- Reps. Thomas Massie, Ky., and Brian Fitzpatrick, Pa., -- voted against the measure. Massie cited the bill's projected increase to the national debt, while Fitzpatrick, who is Catholic, cited the way Medicaid cuts would impact his district. All Democratic members of the House and Senate opposed the bill.
Catholic leaders have alternately praised and criticized various provisions in the legislation. But in a July 1 action alert emailed to its supporters, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops ultimately said the bill "currently fails the poorest families."
Archbishop Timothy P. Broglio, USCCB president and head of the U.S. Archdiocese for the Military Services, said in a July 3 statement after the vote, that he and the bishops had "repeatedly and consistently" urged lawmakers to make sure the bill would help families in need and "to change course" on aspects "that fail the poor and vulnerable."
"The final version of the bill includes unconscionable cuts to healthcare and food assistance, tax cuts that increase inequality, immigration provisions that harm families and children, and cuts to programs that protect God's creation," Archbishop Broglio said. "The bill, as passed, will cause the greatest harm to those who are especially vulnerable in our society. As its provisions go into effect, people will lose access to healthcare and struggle to buy groceries, family members will be separated, and vulnerable communities will be less prepared to cope with environmental impacts of pollution and extreme weather."
The USCCB president said, "More must be done to prevent these devastating effects." He noted the church's own teaching on human dignity and the common good compels it "to redouble our efforts and offer concrete help to those who will be in greater need and continue to advocate for legislative efforts that will provide better possibilities in the future for those in need."
House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., said at a press conference following the vote, "A lot of the estimations about what this legislation would do in a negative manner to communities in my state or any other are far overblown. I can tell you that this bill is going to be a great thing for everybody around the country, my constituents, especially.”
The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office estimated nearly 12 million people will lose health coverage under the legislation.
Ingrid Delgado, national director of public policy and advocacy for The Society of St. Vincent de Paul USA, told OSV News "such large cuts to the social safety net are really concerning, with how it'll impact our most marginalized."
"The Catholic Church approaches both access to food and health care as fundamental human rights," Delgado said. "And so the people who access SNAP in our country and the people who access Medicaid are our most marginalized and poorest brothers and sisters."
Delgado said cuts to those programs could lead to "more people who are uninsured, who don't have food on their tables, and more people facing the risk of homelessness."
The legislation will significantly increase funds for Immigration and Customs Enforcement, also known as ICE, and Customs and Border Patrol as the Trump administration seeks to implement its hardline immigration policies, including the mass deportation of immigrants lacking legal authorization to live and work in the U.S. It authorized about $150 billion in new spending for immigration and border enforcement.
Joan F. Neal, interim executive director of Network, a Catholic social justice lobby, said in a statement, "The damage done by this cruel, un-American bill will be devastating, intergenerational, and require decades-long reform to repair."
"People will die if the country robs millions of us of access to food and health care, creates even more obscene wealth inequality, and funds increasing detention, deportation, and ICE raids. The United States will be unrecognizable, and it will take a very long time to rebuild," Neal said. "This is a moral failure for the lawmakers who passed it and a betrayal of the trust of their constituents who elected them to look after their interests. They should be ashamed of themselves."
But others celebrated a provision in the legislation that would strip funds from Planned Parenthood for only one year -- down from an original proposal of 10 years -- with funding resumed thereafter.
Marjorie Dannenfelser, president of Susan B. Anthony Pro-Life America, told OSV News the day before the House vote that "this is the possible culminating point of the first year where federal taxpayers are not forced to fund Big Abortion and that would be huge."
Dannenfelser said that one year was the most amount of time they could achieve through the bill under Senate rules, which limit policy changes in reconciliation legislation.
"One year is a beginning, and it sets a new precedent, which is exactly what we want," she said.
In a fundraising pitch on its website, Planned Parenthood said the impact of the legislation "will be immediate and devastating."
"As many as 200 Planned Parenthood health centers are at risk of shutting down," they said.
The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office estimated the legislation would increase the deficit by nearly $3.3 trillion from 2025 to 2034. The U.S. national debt currently stands at $36.2 trillion, and has downstream impacts on the rest of society.
A June 26 letter to senators from the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops praised the provision that would strip funds from Planned Parenthood while opposing others that they said would raise taxes "on the working poor while simultaneously giving large tax cuts to the wealthiest." The letter added, "Because of this, millions of poor families will not be able to afford life-saving healthcare and will struggle to buy food for their children. Some rural hospitals will likely close." The bishops called these provisions "unconscionable and unacceptable."
Kate Scanlon is a national reporter for OSV News covering Washington.